Equal theme
 
Get involved
Valid XHTML 1.1

Equality at work – is it still a gender issue?

This debate is now over. Thank you to all who took part. A downloadable video file and a summary of the debate are available below.
Equal-Works guest: Baroness Young of Hornsey, Lola Young, OBE
Moderator: Jeremy Harrison, Equal-Works Editorial Director, Tribal Education and Technology

Gender Debate Summary with Lola Young

 The third Equal-Works live debate was on gender equality. The guest was Baroness Lola Young, former head of culture at GLA, academic and arts consultant.

There is still ambivalence about women with families in the workplace - too few women in boardrooms and senior positions. Women’s pay still lags behind men’s.  There are still stereotypical attitudes, but they also apply to men in occupations like childcare.  There are too few women and men studying science and technology. ‘What’s important is to widen the talent pool by attracting women’, she said.

‘People used to have a better work/life balance’, she pointed out. Now working long hours is a kind of badge of honour. ‘Your working life will be better if you have something outside work.’

Small firms can face problems with equality legislation. Women must not be disadvantaged or disenfranchised, but individual solutions are needed for very small firms.  In the public sector, the Gender Equality Duty sets a framework for the culture we need. ‘Now,’ she said, ‘people just need to get on and do it’.

Women have got to the top of a number of organisations, but there appears to be an ‘iron collar’ that stops women getting the better middle management jobs. ‘We need to see more women at all levels in organisations’.  Only 6% of women are self-employed and setting up businesses. She pointed to research showing African and Caribbean women as the most entrepreneurial. ‘But BME women are less likely to get bank loans than others – if anyone’s risk averse it’s the banks’.

‘The most entrepreneurial people in the world’, she said, ‘are migrants’, and she referred to a recent report showing that among those most likely to encourage their daughters to study and get into work were Muslim families.

Finally we must learn from good experience. ‘One problem’, she said, ‘is rabid short-termism – we’re not great at sharing good practice – some find it easier to reinvent the wheel than look back’.

Questions debated

Question 1

Conclusion 1(11.02 mins): Welcome to Baroness Lola Young; still ambivalence about women with families in the workplace; too few women in boardrooms and senior positions; pay still behind men’s - how long will it take for workplace equality? Stereotypical attitudes still exist - men in childcare occupations suffer from them as well as women.
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 2

Conclusion 2 (8.05 min): Gender and ethnic stereotyping: overcoming personal obstacles; the issue of too few women and men studying science and technology – engineering departments in universities have been suffering from women; the idea that women at work bring a feminine perspective to a role not necessarily true; what’s important is to widen the talent pool by attracting women.
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 3

Conclusion 3 (6.23 mins): Complex schooling issues: people used to have a better work/life balance – now working long hours is a kind of badge of honour; people are not prepared to give job-sharing serious consideration - evidence is you get more for your money; the fact is that your working life will be better if you have something outside work.
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 4

Conclusion 4 (8.44 mins): problems small firms face with equality legislation – must not disadvantage or disenfranchise women, but no need for more legislation – need to work on individual solutions for very small firms – Gender Equality Duty sets a framework in the public sector for the culture we need – people just need to get on and do it – wish more successful women would be less coy about saying how they’ve achieved it.
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 5

Conclusion 5 (5.44 mins): The Glass Ceiling; women have got to the top of a number of sectors and organisations but there appears to be an ‘iron collar’ that restricts progression of women to the better middle management jobs; we need to see more women at all levels in organisations; are women running organisations getting the same salaries as men for the same work? And how many women are running Higher Education institutions?
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 6

Conclusion 6 (10.55 mins): Freedom to choose non-traditional careers: we have strategies, now we just need to get on with it; only 6% of women are self-employed and setting up businesses; people’s attitude to entrepreneurship is beginning to change, maybe the growth rate will improve: women as risk takers - there are many ways in which society differentiates between men and women when they go out and sell ideas; let’s put resources into increasing numbers of women leading businesses, but let’s also work on changing how people think about issues around equality.
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 7

Conclusion 7 (9.08 mins): Research shows African and Caribbean women as the most entrepreneurial – but BME women are less likely to get bank loans than others; if anyone is risk averse it’s the banks; the most entrepreneurial people in the world are migrants – self-employment and entrepreneurialism not panaceas, just tools we should use; a recent report showed that among those most likely to encourage their daughters to study and get into work were Muslim families.
Comments
Be the first to comment

Question 8

Conclusion 8 (8.15 mins): How do we learn from good experience? One problem is rabid short-termism – we’re not great at sharing good practice – some find it easier to reinvent the wheel than look back; in the media, why are women over a certain age put out to pasture while men go on forever? Why can’t we have as many women as men film directors? Why do women seem to find it more difficult to get money for cultural projects?
Comments
Be the first to comment

Recommended website links

Your contributions

The debates are open to all. You will need to register to place comments/questions on the debate pages prior to the live debate, and you can also log on and question the speaker on the day. You can keyboard your point, and the speaker will respond on webcam. Once the speaker is off air, you will be able to continue the discussion with other online users. The debate will be transcribed and made available on the site within a couple of days. If you participate in the online debate, your name and organisation will be displayed unless you specifically request anonymity when you submit your comment. Users are expected to participate in a professional manner – posting of inappropriate comments will result in a bar from further participation in the debate.